Peanut butter chocolate - who did it better?

Not everyone likes peanut butter chocolate, but it is one of Joni's favourites.  
Both Whittakers Peanut Butter and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups were taken to a recent board game day.  Everybody had to taste each and decide who did it better?

The result: Totally split down the middle.  
Here is the comment on each, for and against.

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
There is more saltiness to the Reese's.  There is also a lot more sugar.  There is also a grittiness in the texture that maybe the salt or sugar or maybe a crunchier peanut butter?

Whittakers Peanut Butter Chocolate Block 
The Whittakers is not salty and is less sweet.  It is also creamier and smooth to eat.  The chocolate is their lovely 33% Creamy Milk.

​Which would you prefer?